JumpStart Logo

  JumpStart Tulsa 
 A Smart Start Oklahoma Community Partnership

  Get involved    Find services    Support JumpStart 

Jump HOME
Jump UP
Tulsa Partnership
Smart Start Oklahoma
History
Why early childhood?
Brain research
School readiness
Parents make the difference
Parent events, activities
Pre-K & KG Round-Up
Find services
News & editorials
Learn more!
How you can help!
Quality Early Care & Learning

 


 

 

The ADVERSE CHILDHOOD EXPERIENCES (ACE) Study, and its implications for the early childhood field, were the focus of a JumpStart's Leadership Forum in Tulsa

 

January 26, 2007 - Vincent Felitti, MD - download the flyer


Vincent J. Felitti, MD, is Co-Principal Investigator of the Adverse Childhood Experiences Study, ongoing collaborative research between Kaiser Permanente and the Centers for Disease Control. A graduate of Johns Hopkins Medical School (1962), Dr. Felitti founded the Department of Preventive Medicine for Kaiser Permanente in San Diego, California in 1975, where he served as Chief of Preventive Medicine until March 2001. He is also Clinical Professor of Medicine at University of California, San Diego, a Fellow of The American College of Physicians, and founder of the California Institutes of Preventive Medicine. 

 

This Leadership Forum was sponsored by OICA and Tulsa's JumpStart Community Partnership for Early Childhood Success (Community Service Council).  Partner sponsors:  Tulsa Healthy Start, Child Care Resource Center.

 

Pictured:  Vincent Felitti, M.D. (center) with Community Service Council/JumpStart staff Jan Figart and Talia Shaull. 
More event photos



From "About the Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACE) Study":

Why is it important to know about the Adverse Childhood Experiences Study?

Because it provides compelling evidence that:
·
      ACEs are surprisingly common.
·      They happen even in “the best of families”.
·
      They have long-term, damaging consequences.

The pyramid below helps visualize the process by which harsh experiences such as abuse, neglect, and loss of birth parent(s) during childhood result in health problems in adulthood.

For deeper insight into the definition, frequency, presence, and consequences of Adverse Childhood Experiences, read the downloadable documents available at our ACE-related Publications page.

The True Nature of Preventive Medicine

 

 

More about ACE:

The ACE website
 

About the Adverse Childhood Experiences Study
ACE Publications

The Origins of Addiction: Evidence from the Adverse Childhood Experiences Study
The Relationship of Adverse Childhood Experiences to Adult Health:  Turning Gold Into Lead

 

Adverse Childhood Experiences Issue Briefs - Oklahoma Institute for Child Advocacy

 


Photos from the Leadership Forum on Adverse Childhood Experiences


   
  
   
 


   
 

 

Tulsa World stories, by Ginnie Graham, January 2007:  (These stories appear below.)

 

1/3/07--Oklahoma's poor health rankings could be a result of how many bad things children experience and witness while growing up, according to emerging research.
 
1/27/07--The risk factors for the nation's top 10 causes of death are determined in early childhood, the director of an ongoing health study in California said.

1//28/07--When a mother is beaten and abused, the baby lying in a crib can sense the tension, and the teenager hiding upstairs knows what is happening.

1/29/07--Children living in a home with an alcoholic adult are twice as likely to engage in risky behaviors as they grow up, according to a national and state report.

 

Study:  Ill health a chronic problem
By GINNIE GRAHAM World Staff Writer
1/3/2007

View in Print (PDF) Format

New research shows that negative experiences during childhood could affect a person's health later in life.

Oklahoma's poor health rankings could be a result of how many bad things children experience and witness while growing up, according to emerging research.

Those negative experiences could range from how a divorce is handled to the extent a child suffers abuse. A connection is being made between the number of such childhood experiences and the physical health of adults.

Through January, the Oklahoma Institute for Child Advocacy will be releasing five briefs detailing the Adverse Childhood Experience Study with Oklahoma data included. The first two briefs were issued Tuesday.

"It's pretty overwhelming, and each issue merits attention," Executive Director Anne Roberts said. "Basically, bad things that children are around and experience are linked to future adult health issues.

"We've always known about the psychological stress. Now, there is a link to physical health such as heart disease and diabetes," she said.

"And this discusses not only what the child personally goes through, but the type of home environment a child is raised in."

The study -- an ongoing project of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the Department of Preventive Medicine at Kaiser Permanente in San Diego -- has been tracking more than 17,000 middle-class people to determine how childhood experiences affect adult health.

"The study looks at the whole environment," Roberts said. "It is not just about children, but about the entire family. This is something we can relate to and do something about."

In December, Men's Health magazine ranked Tulsa 96th and Oklahoma City 92nd out of 100 cities in overall health, and the United Health Foundation ranked Oklahoma 44th in the nation for health status.

Last year, a CDC report put Oklahoma as the 13th-fattest state, and Self magazine ranks Tulsa 94th and Oklahoma City 98th out of 100 cities in health.

"Some of the diseases we have now are behavior-related," Roberts said. "We smoke too much, we eat too much, we don't exercise, and that is why we get sick. But there is a missing link. This can help explain why we smoke in the first place."

The first issue brief gives an overview of the California study and how each county ranks based on the formula used in that project.

According to the rankings, children in most of the counties in southeastern Oklahoma are more likely to experience adversity than those in other parts of the state. Tulsa County ranked 31st.

The study relies on 10 risk factors: emotional abuse, physical abuse, sexual abuse, emotional neglect, physical neglect, mother treated violently, household substance abuse, household mental illness, parental separation or divorce and incarcerated household member.

Almost three-quarters of the study's participants had experienced one or more of the factors. One in six experienced two factors, and one in eight people experienced four or more.

"It is surprising how frequent these issues are," Roberts said. "Adverse childhood experiences happen much more than we think. These are not disadvantaged or poor people. These are working, middle-class, fully functioning adults we can all relate to."

The study showed that people with four or more adverse factors were twice as likely to be smokers, 12 times more likely to have attempted suicide, seven times more likely to be an alcoholic and 10 times more likely to have injected illegal drugs.

Higher adverse factors also show a link to other behaviors, such as overeating and promiscuity.

The second issue brief details child mistreatment. Policy suggestions include creating new diagnostic tools for health professionals and investing in child-abuse prevention programs.

Because of how Oklahoma records abuse and neglect statistics, the issue brief lumps the five risk factors dealing with abuse and neglect into one report, Roberts said.

About one-third of Oklahoma's child abuse and neglect occurs in Tulsa or Oklahoma counties.

Counties considered the most problematic for child abuse and neglect are Adair, Woodward, Choctaw, Pushmataha, Atoka, Coal and Garvin.

The remaining issue briefs will spotlight domestic violence, mental health, substance abuse and absent parents.

The institute will released the annual Kids Count child well-being report Jan. 25. Dr. Vincent J. Felitti, founder of the California study, visited Tulsa on Jan. 26 to discuss the research.

By GINNIE GRAHAM World Staff Writer
1/27/2007
 
A study finds that risk factors are determined early, its director says at a Tulsa lecture.
 
The risk factors for the nation's top 10 causes of death are determined in early childhood, the director of an ongoing health study in California said.
 
Dr. Vincent Felliti said the public health problems facing adults can be traced to the number of negative experiences in childhood, based on his Adverse Childhood Experiences Study.
 
"We found many chronic diseases in adults are determined many years earlier in their childhood, not by childhood disease like I once thought, but by their experiences in childhood," he said.
 
Felliti presented his findings Friday at Oklahoma State University-Tulsa in an appearance sponsored by the Oklahoma Institute for Child Advocacy and the Tulsa Community Service Council.
 
The study has been tracking the health of about 17,500 middle-class, middle-age people in California. It is a project of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the Department of Preventive Medicine at Kaiser Permanente in San Diego.
 
The project got started when Felliti noticed that many of the successful people in his weight-loss program dropped out. Investigation showed that the problems were not about weight but about childhood psychological trauma.
 
Adult risk behaviors such as smoking, overeating, substance abuse or promiscuity are often masks for other problems, he said.
 
"It is easy to blow them off as bad habits, destructive behaviors or addictive personalities," Felliti said. "It is comfortable to hide the functionality of those aspects. What needs attention is what is the function of those and what makes it hard to give them up?"
 
The study gave a number to 10 negative childhood experiences such as abuse, divorce and having an incarcerated parent.
 
The more negative experiences a child went through, the more likely he is to engage in risky behaviors as an adult. Those behaviors lead to public health problems such as obesity and heart disease, diabetes and sexually transmitted diseases.
 
Interventions include prevention programs to protect children and changes in routine medical care to explore the psychological aspects of patient care, Felliti said.
 
To treat patients more thoroughly, the California center changed its initial questionnaire to include more personal history in addition to biological health, Felliti said.
 
"It is feasible, affordable and acceptable," he said. "It will save primary medical care physicians from treating symptoms and deal with the underlying causes. We feel it is an ideal standard as an entry mechanism into medical care."
 
The study did not break down when the negative experiences happened in the patients' lives.
 
"But in looking back on what we know, the earlier in life those experiences occurred, the more destructive it is later in life," Felliti said. "Those are more likely hard-wired when the brain is being formed and not much has occurred to aid in resiliency.
 
"Resiliency is not innate," he said. "It is created by good life experiences by another person who cares, even if that person is peripheral."
By GINNIE GRAHAM World Staff Writer
1/28/2007
 
When a mother is beaten and abused, the baby lying in a crib can sense the tension, and the teenager hiding upstairs knows what is happening.
 
As the children grow, the infant may experience stunted brain development or attachment problems. Older children may face a host of health issues including substance abuse and depression.
 
The Oklahoma Institute for Child Advocacy has issued a series of briefs dissecting portions of the Adverse Childhood Experience Study, which details how childhood experiences affect adult behavior.
 
One brief examines the effect of domestic violence toward the mother or stepmother in a home.
 
"Mothers are usually the primary caregivers for the kids, and it simply makes children more fearful, like being in a war zone," said Executive Director Anne Roberts. "Imagine how unstable the home would feel if the mother were under constant threat."
 
When children are exposed to domestic violence, other problems usually are occurring in the household.
 
Child abuse and neglect is about 15 times more likely to happen in homes where domestic violence takes place. About 25 percent of men who are abusers also are addicted to drugs or alcohol, the report states.
 
"The whole point of the (national) study is showing that these issues happen in clusters," Roberts said. "If a lot of domestic violence occurs, there is probably substance abuse or criminal activity going on.
 
"As a child advocate, I am alarmed at the domestic violence rate. We now understand it is not only just what happens to children but what happens around them that affects them as they grow."
 
In ranking the best to worst counties based on protective order filings, Tulsa ranks 57th out of 77. Tulsa County has a ratio of 20.2 out of 1,000 women filing for a protective order, according to the report using 2003 statistics.
 
The number of protective orders could be interpreted to mean more victims are getting out of violent relationships, say some domestic violence researchers.
 
The California study is an ongoing project of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the Department of Preventive Medicine at Kaiser Permanente in San Diego.
 
The study has been tracking more than 17,000 middle-income people to determine how their childhood experiences affect their lifestyles and decision making.
 
The study shows a connection between the number of negative childhood experiences and adult physical health. Negative childhood experiences range from nasty divorces to homelessness and parental drug addiction.
 
With domestic violence, the impact on the child depends on when the violence occurs. In infants, the stress leads to the release of the hormone cortisol, which can disrupt brain development.
 
Older children often show signs of post-traumatic stress disorder, have more illnesses and participate in more risky behavior as adults, the report states.
 
"This is emerging research that shows the devastating health impact domestic violence has on children," Roberts said.
 
Policy recommendations include establishing a state-level mechanism to bring together plans from a variety of agencies and establish clear communications between the domestic violence and substance abuse fields.
 
PROTECTIVE ORDERS ISSUED
Ten worst counties (ratio: per 1,000 women)
McCurtain - 38.1
Choctaw - 34.1
Cherokee - 29.7
Adair - 27.6
Pushmataha - 27.6
Greer - 26.3
Sequoyah - 26.2
Harmon - 25.4
Caddo - 25.4
Coal - 14.9
 
Ten best counties
Carter - 3.5
Marshall - 4.6
Harper - 5.7
Cimarron - 6.2
Love - 7.5
Jackson - 7.9
Cleveland - 8.1
Canadian - 8.2
Woods - 8.3
Murray - 8.5
By GINNIE GRAHAM World Staff Writer
1/29/2007
 
As children witness adult dysfunctions, they become more likely to adopt them.
 
Children living in a home with an alcoholic adult are twice as likely to engage in risky behaviors as they grow up, according to a national and state report.
 
As children witness multiple adult dysfunctions, they will cope by overeating, smoking, becoming promiscuous or using drugs and alcohol.
 
For children exposed to adults going through severe psychological stress from mental illness or substance abuse, they tend to have higher rates of divorce, unemployment, criminal histories and domestic violence.
 
"Americans think that children are resilient and can get over bad things that happen to them," said Anne Roberts, executive director of the Oklahoma Institute for Child Advocacy.
 
"But what we are seeing is that adverse childhood experiences are difficult for children to come through and are interrelated. We need to invest now with our children, find out what is going on and provide treatment before they pick up risky behaviors that lead to disease."
 
The Oklahoma Institute for Child Advocacy is releasing a series of issue briefs detailing how childhood experiences impact adult behavior. They use the national Adverse Childhood Experience Study as a model and add state data.
 
The state brief examines the impact of adult substance abuse and mental illness on children.
 
Roberts said the data may be limited.  "Those with psychological distress who have children suffering at home
are probably trying to keep it a secret," Roberts said. "We may not have a true picture of the burdens our children are carrying."
 
Tulsa County ranked among the worst regions for adults experiencing severe psychological stress and for adults addicted to drugs or alcohol.
 
Oklahoma has the nation's highest rate of mental illness at an estimated 11 percent of the adult population. The national average is 9.2 percent.
 
About 140,000 Oklahomans need treatment for alcohol addiction, and about 21,000 Oklahomans need treatment for drug addictions.
 
"The take-away message is that we can treat mental illness," Roberts said. "People with mental illness can lead healthy, productive lives. We just have to have and provide the resources for them."
 
Pregnant women are particularly at risk, the study shows.  Of the nearly 38,000 Oklahoma women needing substance abuse treatment, about 3,000 are pregnant. One in five pregnant Oklahoma women smoke. Of those who quit smoking during pregnancy, about 59 percent resume after delivery.
 
Policy recommendations include expanding drug and mental health courts and improving the coordination between adult and pediatric care when mental health or substance abuse services are involved.
 
Roberts suggests developing a way to co-manage families in crisis, meaning those treating the adults and children are communicating about the therapies being used.